Click here for Part 1
Click here for Part 2
If the BCS never changed, it may be preparing for Year 17 in 2014 instead of being replaced by the impending four-team college football playoff.
Click here for Part 2
If the BCS never changed, it may be preparing for Year 17 in 2014 instead of being replaced by the impending four-team college football playoff.
Whether that’s a good thing or not, isn’t really debatable –
the BCS
was terrible. Or was it?
In fact, for the first 8 years of the BCS, the system was
actually working out extremely well. Well, sort of. Oh, there’s always a "sort
of" with the BCS.
In the first 8 years, the BCS set the stage for two of the
greatest games in college football history – the 2003 Fiesta Bowl and the 2006
Rose Bowl – that could not have happened in a pre-BCS world thanks to the Rose
Bowl’s Pac-10 and Big Ten tie-ins. For that alone, the BCS should be applauded.
But the other title games left a lot to be desired. From
Miami left out in 2000 to Oregon left out in 2001 to #1 USC somehow now making
the title game in 2003, the system seemed to do everything except succeed. It
made for such a strange dynamic. Look at the two title games the Rose Bowl
hosted in that time. One, Miami/Nebraska, was probably the worst title game in
college football history. The other, Texas/USC, was possibly the greatest.
One long-forgotten aspect of the original BCS is how it did
not destroy – at least not completely – New Year’s Day. With only four games,
the season was always wrapped up by January 3 or 4. The title game was never
played 10 days into the New Year. There were no Jan. 4 Sugar
Bowls played in front of 20,000 empty seats.
Then came the dreaded double hosting model – an idea so bad,
it should reside next to Baseball Night in America in the bad idea Hall of
Fame. The BCS added that extra game under pressure from Congress and the system
would begin its descent. The double hosting model ruined, well, just about
everything.
Teams, like Ohio State in 2006, waited 50+ days to play a
title game. There were the aforementioned weeknight, post-holiday bowl games
that drew flies. The bowl hosted the title game always ignored the first bowl
game, leading to debacles such as the Sugar Bowl in 2011 selecting Virginia
Tech because they had been there before and were familiar with the game.
Yes, familiarity was a reason why Virginia Tech made
a supposedly prestigious bowl game in 2011.
It also unnecessarily dragged out the bowl season. The
reason New Year’s Day worked in the past – and why it will next year – is that
casual fans were easily able to carve out a day or two to watch football. The
bloated, double-hosting BCS required four nights that, again this cannot be
overstated, took place after the holidays ended.
That part has been righted and starting next year, New
Year’s Day, and New Year’s Eve, will return to hosting the most important bowl
games. It’s a move, oh, 20 years overdue. But next
year’s bowl schedule will be better than this
year’s lineup.
Regular Season
Record: 88-76-2
Best Bet: 6-9
Upset Special: 9-6
Best Bet: 6-9
Upset Special: 9-6
North Texas (-6.5)
over UNLV
I watch a lot of college football. Have you noticed? So despite having access to just about every college football game played in a given week, save for the elusive Pac-12, I have seen a grand total of six plays combined from these two teams. And all six of them occurred when I watched UNLV try to come back against Utah State when that night’s Notre Dame game had me wanting to rip my eyeballs out.
I watch a lot of college football. Have you noticed? So despite having access to just about every college football game played in a given week, save for the elusive Pac-12, I have seen a grand total of six plays combined from these two teams. And all six of them occurred when I watched UNLV try to come back against Utah State when that night’s Notre Dame game had me wanting to rip my eyeballs out.
So I haven’t watched North Texas for a second this year. I
know UNLV beat San Diego State like a drum to finish the regular season, but
Good Lord, did they look awful in trying to make that comeback against Utah
State. While UNLV hasn’t been a to a bowl in 13 years, North Texas hasn’t been
to one since 2004 and Denton, Texas is a lot closer to Dallas than Las Vegas.
The Mean
Green faithful are really excited – as they should – to play a New Year’s
Day bowl game in the Cotton Bowl stadium, even if most mock it. I’m making this
pick based solely on motivation and crowd support. Do not take it to the bank.
Georgia (-9) over
Nebraska
Nebraska has to be sick of playing SEC teams in Florida on New Year’s Day, eh? Two years ago, it was South Carolina. Last year, it was Georgia.
Nebraska has to be sick of playing SEC teams in Florida on New Year’s Day, eh? Two years ago, it was South Carolina. Last year, it was Georgia.
You would think they’d have a chance this year because of
Aaron Murray. If this was last year’s Nebraska team – or even the 2011 version
– I might be inclined to agree with you. But this is this year’s Nebraska team
and they aren’t very good. They are a Hail Mary away from behind the bottom
team on the Big Ten pecking order. They beat absolutely no one of consquence,
unless you consider 7-5 Michigan good, and ended the season in disastrous
fashion.
Meanwhile, Georgia overcame the loss of QB Aaron Murray to
stun archrival Georgia Tech in the season finale. Nebraska wants to rally
around an embattled coach. Georgia has already rallied around its injured star
and a star-crossed season in which everything and anything went wrong.
Georgia will end this season on a high note because it
deserves to. Also, it’s like three touchdowns better than Nebraska.
South Carolina (+1)
over Wisconsin *Best Bet*
This line annoys me. Wisconsin’s last game was a beatdown loss at home against Penn State. South Carolina’s last game was a beatdown win at home against Clemson.
This line annoys me. Wisconsin’s last game was a beatdown loss at home against Penn State. South Carolina’s last game was a beatdown win at home against Clemson.
What am I missing here? Ugh, I know whenever a line seems
wrong, Vegas ends up being right. But I refuse to believe Wisconsin is a better
team than South Carolina. And I don’t believe the Gamecocks won’t show up – it
may be a close game, like last year’s Outback Bowl, but Spurrier will come out
on top.
LSU (-7) over Iowa
I am so glad that this might be the last year of the ESPN-inspired “SEC-Big Ten roadblock” that has resulted in a seemingly never-ending stream of SEC buttwhoopings to start off the New Year. Remember in 2010, when the two Big Ten Michigan schools lost bowl games by, I believe, a combined score of 175-6?
I am so glad that this might be the last year of the ESPN-inspired “SEC-Big Ten roadblock” that has resulted in a seemingly never-ending stream of SEC buttwhoopings to start off the New Year. Remember in 2010, when the two Big Ten Michigan schools lost bowl games by, I believe, a combined score of 175-6?
As in 2010, the Big Ten got two deserving teams into the
BCS. The problem? The rest of the league sucks. I know Zach Mettenberger is
hurt and won’t play. It doesn’t matter. If LSU didn’t throw the ball once,
they’d win by 10. They will likely throw it, thus they will win by a lot more
than 10.
I don’t want to disparage Iowa – they had a very solid
season and they had nothing but good losses. But they were still losses. This
game could play out similarly to Iowa’s loss to Ohio State or Wisconsin, where
they battled for three quarters but eventually fell off.
So at least this game has that going for it, right? It could
be close at halftime…
Stanford (-4.5) over
Michigan State
I have no good insight here. These teams are mirror images of each other. It will be a battle of wills, strength and determination.
I have no good insight here. These teams are mirror images of each other. It will be a battle of wills, strength and determination.
And when I say that, I mean turnovers. Whoever commits more
turnovers will lose the game. Stanford has been here before – this is their
fourth BCS bowl in a row. Michigan State has not – this is their first Rose
Bowl in 25 years*. I’m going with the calm, cool Stanford demeanor and betting
that Michigan State makes one mistake too many.
*Watch this. Love this. "We did it! We did it! We did it!"
UCF (+16) over Baylor
*Upset Special*
I love UCF in this game. They have been my upset special twice – on the road against Penn State and on the road against Louisville – and they came through in spectacular fashion both times. Why does no one believe in this UCF team? They have an NFL quarterback. They have athletes all over the field. The defense can be questionable but can make big plays. Their only loss was a 3-point defeat to Top 10 South Carolina. What am I missing?
I love UCF in this game. They have been my upset special twice – on the road against Penn State and on the road against Louisville – and they came through in spectacular fashion both times. Why does no one believe in this UCF team? They have an NFL quarterback. They have athletes all over the field. The defense can be questionable but can make big plays. Their only loss was a 3-point defeat to Top 10 South Carolina. What am I missing?
As for Baylor, I haven’t loved them all year and have picked
against them repeatedly, which hasn’t been the best course of action. Except
that game against Oklahoma State. My feelings on Baylor? They are really good
but a down year for the Big 12, in addition to a soft nonconference schedule,
has skewed popular opinion.
In my mind, Baylor should be favored by about 5 points. So I’m
getting an extra 11. Easy money baby!
Alabama (-15) over
Oklahoma
This is a pretty easy game to pick because Alabama is miles better than Oklahoma. It all comes down to one question – does Alabama show up? Their no show in the 2009 Sugar Bowl against Utah has become stuff of legend, even if that Utah team is way better than people give it credit.
This is a pretty easy game to pick because Alabama is miles better than Oklahoma. It all comes down to one question – does Alabama show up? Their no show in the 2009 Sugar Bowl against Utah has become stuff of legend, even if that Utah team is way better than people give it credit.
To me, this game feels a lot like the 2010 Sugar Bowl where
a Florida team that had its national title dreams ripped away in their finale
rallied around Tim Tebow – insert A.J. McCarron here – and delivered one of the
most epic beatdowns in New Year’s Day history. It may not be 54-3. But I don’t
think it’ll be close.
Missouri (-1) over
Oklahoma State
I believe the SEC is better than the Big 12. Like, by a lot. And the Cotton Bowl in recent years has become a game of horrors for the Big 12, as they have lost the last five games and the last three haven’t been close. The last Big 12 team to win the Cotton Bowl? Missouri. They win again. Missouri that is, not the Big 12.
I believe the SEC is better than the Big 12. Like, by a lot. And the Cotton Bowl in recent years has become a game of horrors for the Big 12, as they have lost the last five games and the last three haven’t been close. The last Big 12 team to win the Cotton Bowl? Missouri. They win again. Missouri that is, not the Big 12.
Ohio State (-2.5)
over Clemson
The more I think about this game, the more I get excited about it. It really is what bowl games – at least of the non-title variety – should be about. Two teams with great offenses, no defense and playing with nothing to lose to get a huge season-ending victory. While this game marks the end of an era for Clemson, with the loss of Tahj Boyd and the likely loss of Sammy Watkins, this feels like Ohio State’s first game in a road to redemption and a playoff berth in 2014.
The more I think about this game, the more I get excited about it. It really is what bowl games – at least of the non-title variety – should be about. Two teams with great offenses, no defense and playing with nothing to lose to get a huge season-ending victory. While this game marks the end of an era for Clemson, with the loss of Tahj Boyd and the likely loss of Sammy Watkins, this feels like Ohio State’s first game in a road to redemption and a playoff berth in 2014.
Clemson played 3 big games this year. They beat Georgia.
They got embarrassed by Florida State and South Carolina. Ohio State may not be
as good as any of those teams – but I can’t trust Clemson in this spot. Not
when they gave up 70 during their last bowl trip. Not when they haven’t beaten
South Carolina in half-a-decade. Not when they have lost almost every big game
they’ve played in the past 3 years, with the notable exception of this year’s
opener.
And I’ll take Urban Meyer over Dabo Swinney in a big-game
coaching matchup every day of the week.
Houston (+3) over
Vanderbilt
Houston is either the luckiest team in the country or the most underrated. They were one of the nation’s best in turnover margin, which could mask a lot of deficiencies. On the other hand, their four losses all came by one score or less to teams with at least 8 wins – BYU, Cincinnati, Louisville and UCF. Vanderbilt likewise only lost to good teams, but they tended to be of the blowout variety.
Houston is either the luckiest team in the country or the most underrated. They were one of the nation’s best in turnover margin, which could mask a lot of deficiencies. On the other hand, their four losses all came by one score or less to teams with at least 8 wins – BYU, Cincinnati, Louisville and UCF. Vanderbilt likewise only lost to good teams, but they tended to be of the blowout variety.
It seems a bit foolish to even be making a pick now since
any job opening – cough, Texas – means another round of rumors for James
Franklin. And if I’m Franklin, I’d be on the first flight to Austin. I respect
what he’s done at Vanderbilt but that program will never consistently beat out
the Georgia’s and South Carolina’s of the world. And his rise coincided with a
rare trip to the abyss for Tennessee.
That stuff aside, I think Houston is better than people
think, I don’t think Vanderbilt is as good as people think and I bet Houston
will be highly motivated to make a loud statement for the maligned
American Athletic Conference. Remember UConn over South Carolina
in 2009? Okay, you probably don’t. But I do. And that’s what I forsee
happening.
Ball State (-9) over
Arkansas State
Arkansas State lost its coach to Boise State. As I type this, Ball State hasn’t lost their hotshot coach, Pete Lembo, to anybody.
Arkansas State lost its coach to Boise State. As I type this, Ball State hasn’t lost their hotshot coach, Pete Lembo, to anybody.
Also, Ball State is a 10-win team that has only lost to Northern
Illinois since September. I think the MAC is marginally better than the Sun
Belt. I think Ball State is decidedly better than Arkanas State. Not thrilled
with giving 9 points in what will essentially be a home game, but I have to go
with the better team.
My title game pick will come after the holidays…enjoy all
the football.
Follow me on Twitter
UCF sucks.
ReplyDeleteWell, no, not exactly.
Delete