When Did We Start Believing Everything on the Internet?

I feel very old every time I tell people I didn’t have a work email address when I started my first job.

My first job was being a daily newspaper reporter for The Chronicle in Willimantic, Connecticut. The paper had a website, but our articles were not posted the same day it ran in print. In fact, there was a lag of about a week before they went online.

internet lies gif
Similarly, I did not have a work email address. I had my personal AOL email address, which was helpful for getting press releases and statements, but the vast majority were still received by fax. Yeah, 2003 was a very long time ago.

But the anecdote that gets my younger co-workers laughing is when a local First Selectman emailed me a quote for a story. It led to this conversation with my then-editor.

“I got a quote from the First Selectman.”
“He called you?”
“No, he emailed me.”
“How do you know it’s him?”

I didn’t know how to answer. Of course, it’s him. It was his official town email address. My editor wasn’t having it. We couldn’t accept quotes via email unless we have verbal confirmation that the email was sent by the person providing the quotes.

At the time, it made me furious. My job was easier via email! In retrospect, my editor may have had a point.

The Internet is Not a Source

I started college in 1999 and one of the biggest perks was a cable modem. Instead of dial up, the entire Internet was there to be devoured in seconds. Napster was taking off, so I had access to more music than ever. I loved pro wrestling, and I discovered how many wrestling fans were out there through message boards. The world was changing.

Despite it all, I never trusted what I read online. How could I? Literally anyone could publish on the Internet. Hell, my friends and I were posting our own blogs. If we could put stuff out there, we knew anyone can.

Our professors weren’t feeling the Internet either. If you cited a source from a webpage, your professor would not accept it. It needed to be from an actual book.

It seems so silly to think about now but, duh, you can’t believe everything you read on the Internet. Thinking about this has been driving me crazy because it seems like all people do now is believe nonsense on the Internet.

Debunking Lies is Impossible Now

The most frustrating aspect of the past three years and the rise of the far right, Trump and racism, is how lies become accepted truths. We all agree that big lies, like the Comet Pizza nonsense, are beyond the pale and only lunatics believe that stuff.

It’s the little lies that are the problem. It’s our President saying the border is a national emergency, when it is obviously and demonstrably not. It’s his supporters believing it’s a national emergency, when it is obviously and demonstrably not.

I’ve seen this first hand too many times to count on Twitter, when a right-wing nut will tell me something that is incredibly untrue, usually something Trump has said. To back it up, they’ll send me a link a dubious site like Daily Caller or Breitbart to support them. When I provide a link to a reputable source, their response is “fake news” and nothing is ever accomplished.

Part of me is impressed Russia’s misinformation campaign worked so well. More of me is worried about today’s education system.

Why are Americans so stupid in 2019? Why do we believe everything on the Internet? Why are adults in this country so resistant to learning facts and expanding their horizons?

As much as I and others want to scream from the rooftops that we can’t believe lies, it doesn’t matter because it will only force these people to retreat further into believe these lies.

In reality, this is a problem of education in this country. Whatever we’ve been doing is not working. Our country is not going to survive another generation of stupidity.

Email me

Comments