College Football 1993: The Peak of New Year’s Day

1993 produced the biggest regular season game and best single day of college football in my entire life.

nd florida state 1993
Of course, college football being college football, the sport has ensured that neither ever happens again.

What made the 1993 college football season feel so special was the wide variety of teams involved in the national championship race and the amazing stories that captivated the sports world that fall. For the first time, it felt like college football had broken free from the “regional sport” stereotype and became a true, national sport.

With the notable exception of the Pac-10, every major conference had a national contender when November rolled around. The storylines, coaches, and players involved made for a riveting, compelling fall. Prior to 1993, most college football seasons at the very top revolved around a few teams that had a chance to win it all. But in 1993, it felt like anything was possible.

The biggest regular season game, obviously, was Florida State at Notre Dame in mid-November that was the Game of the Century in every sense of the word. Florida State, coached by Bobby Bowden and led by eventual Heisman Trophy winner Charlie Ward, felt like a team from the future. They had athletes upon athletes all over the field, with a wide-open offense, which ran over teams all year. On the flip side, Notre Dame was not a flashy Notre Dame, but it ran through its season undefeated, and the game would be aired on NBC, which had only recently started airing every Notre Dame home game.

The game was so big that ESPN’s then-fledgling pregame show, College Gameday, decided to make its first-ever road trip. While today networks send crews to every big game, this was completely different and unprecedented. ESPN wasn’t even airing the game, why were there?

They were there because it was that big. Add in the blue-gray November sky and the historic Notre Dame Stadium, and the game was more Hollywood script than pigskin clash. The epic intro narrated by Bob Costas about how every kid grows up dreaming of playing in that type of game gives me goosebumps to this day.

Notre Dame won that day 31-24. It is estimated that 40 million people watched that Saturday afternoon. Yes, 40 million. To give an indication of how big that was in 1993 – Home Improvement was the #1 show on television that season and the episode that aired three days before Notre Dame/Florida State drew 32.9 million viewers.

In the 29 years that have passed, there has only been one other non-conference 1 vs 2 game in the regular season. It was an early September game between Ohio State and a Texas team that would lose 3 games. With the increase in conference sizes and the focus on the playoff, we’ll never see a game like it again.

The most remarkable part of 1993 is how the biggest regular season game in history was merely a prelude to the most insane finish to a season, maybe ever.

bc nd 1993
The following week, Notre Dame lost its perfect season at home to Boston College 41-39 in Boston College’s biggest football ever and the game that marked the last time Notre Dame was #1 for nearly two decades.

That same day, #5 Ohio State, with only a tie on its record, did what Ohio State became famous for in the 1990s – lose to an underdog Michigan team. The loss sent Wisconsin to its first Rose Bowl in decades, which the Badgers secured by beating Michigan State in Tokyo. Yes, Tokyo. Yes, I love college football.

But Saturday, November 20, 1993 had more in store. Undefeated West Virginia, in its biggest home game in school history, became the first Big East team to take down Miami. The most memorable part of that game came when the West Virginia crowd, in an age before smartphones, found out that Notre Dame lost on the scoreboard, and they lost their minds.

Do you want more? We got more. Auburn beat Alabama 22-14 on that same day, closing out an 11-0 regular season. It was a game no one watched on television. Auburn was on probation and part of that probation meant none of its games would be televised. Yes, Auburn finished an undefeated season at home by beating #11 Alabama and you had to be there in Jordan-Hare Stadium to watch it. How is college football so awesome?

I’ve mentioned all of this, yet November 20, 1993, is somehow not the best day of college football of my lifetime. In fact, it wasn’t even the best of that year. Because New Year’s Day 1994 provided the most outlandish, ridiculous lineup of games in postseason history, and each delivered in spades.

The Fiesta Bowl selected Arizona to play Miami, which meant the game had to be moved up to a 1pm start because a Pac-10 team was contractually prevented from playing opposite the Rose Bowl. That game featured Arizona obliterating Miami and essentially ending The U’s dynasty, which only resurfaced briefly in the early 2000s.

The fun, though, was just getting started. The Rose Bowl featured Wisconsin, making its first trip to Pasadena in 31 years, sneaking past hometown UCLA 21-16.

At the same time, the first Cotton Bowl to ever be played in the dark, moving into the Fiesta Bowl's vacated 4:30 p.m. slot on NBC, took place as 1-loss Notre Dame took on 1-loss Texas A&M. Notre Dame felt aggrieved that it would possibly lose the national title to a Florida State team it had beat in the regular season. Texas A&M was carrying the weight of the Southwest Conference, which had not even scored a touchdown in the Cotton Bowl in four years. Yes, the SWC champion – Texas in 1990 and Texas A&M in 1991 and 1992 – had been held without a touchdown in the Cotton Bowl for 180 minutes of football action. The game rocked, as Notre Dame pulled out a thrilling 28-24 victory.

We weren’t close to done yet. Undefeated West Virginia was sent to the Sugar Bowl, to play Steve Spurrier’s Florida. The Mountaineers, like Notre Dame, were an aggrieved party feeling that its undefeated season deserved to end in a title shot. They didn’t get it, and they probably didn’t deserve it. Florida wiped the Superdome turf with West Virginia, winning a 41-7 laugher.

1994 orange bowl
The nightcap was the Orange Bowl, matching undefeated Nebraska with Florida State. Tom Osborne’s Nebraska was famously an 17 1/2-point underdog – yes, 17 1/2 points, read that again – vs Florida State. The impending blowout never materialized, and instead a truly remarkable slugfest broke out. Florida State eventually won 18-16, with a famous finish that included a bizarre review from refs of a last second play, years before instant replay, and one last kick by Nebraska. It went sailing wide left, and Bobby Bowden had his national title.

It's hard to overstate how insane that New Year’s Day was, starting at 11am in the morning on ESPN and ending sometime past midnight in Miami. I was 11 years old, and I truly felt like sports on television would never be better.

Sadly, I was right. New Year’s Day 1994 was the last time that the big Four bowl games – Cotton, Sugar, Rose, and Orange – were played on the same day.

For the 1994 season, NBC played the Orange Bowl on New Year’s Night, but it was a twist. That was a Sunday, and for years all college games moved to Monday when that happened. However, NBC had the NFL playoffs during the day and nothing at night, so it moved the Orange Bowl to its own slot vs no competition. Tom Osborne finally got his national title, and the next day’s glut of games on New Year’s Day felt meaningless.

Playing a national championship decider before New Year’s Day? How stupid is that? I’m sure college football wouldn’t make that mistake again.

By 1995, the new Bowl Alliance made its first appearance, moving a supposed title game to January 2, but it only worked once. The Big Ten/Pac-10 agreement for the Rose Bowl meant two split national titles between 1993 and the advent of the BCS, along with the 1996 season where #1 and #2 played in different bowl games and both lost.

1993 was the absolute peak of the college football bowl system. Everything worked to perfection, starting with that glorious Saturday afternoon in South Bend.

In retrospect, it may have worked too well. Because TV execs and school leaders saw the amount of money that could be made – and the amount of money that was being left on the table.

The 1993 season ended with college football’s last true New Year’s Day.

It would be another a decade-plus until the stars aligned for college football to produce another perfect, peak season. 

Follow me on Twitter

Comments